Government Unveils Response to Dartmoor Independent Review Findings

Today, on Wednesday, April 10th, the government has released its official response to the Independent Review focused on Protected Site Management on Dartmoor. You can read the full government response here.

This response outlines key priorities aimed at supporting farmers in Dartmoor to sustainably produce food while maintaining viable agricultural businesses and safeguarding critical habitats and biodiversity in the area.

Among the highlighted initiatives are enhancing farmers’ trust in Environmental Land Management schemes, including transitions from Higher Level Stewardship (HLS) agreements; fostering collaboration between Natural England and local commoners; and establishing a comprehensive strategy and ongoing governance for Dartmoor.

This announcement follows a recent meeting between Environment Secretary Steve Barclay and local commoners, alongside various stakeholders, to explore a long-term vision for Dartmoor’s management.

Environment Secretary Steve Barclay remarked:

I have listened to the challenges faced by those living and working on Dartmoor, and our response emphasizes the vital role of farmers in maintaining the diverse and healthy ecosystems that support food production.

I would like to extend my gratitude to David Fursdon and the review panel for their significant contributions, and I look forward to continuing our collaboration to safeguard and enhance this remarkable landscape.

A central recommendation from the Review is the establishment of a Land Use Management Group (LUMG) tasked with developing a multifunctional land use framework and a long-range plan for Dartmoor.

The Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (Defra) has confirmed that the LUMG will be inaugurated later this year and will operate for a two-year period. An independent chair will be appointed by Defra, with the Dartmoor National Park Authority providing secretariat support on a day-to-day basis, funded by Defra.

In addition, Defra aims to simplify how land managers can comprehend site designations and associated obligations, particularly for those farming on Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSIs). Enhancing transparency in monitoring and evaluating these sites is also a priority.

The government’s response acknowledges the pressing need for improved collaboration among all stakeholders, ensuring that commoners receive the guidance and support necessary to take advantage of opportunities within the Environmental Land Management schemes.

Marian Spain, Chief Executive of Natural England, stated:

We are pleased with the review, which articulates a clear and optimistic vision for Dartmoor. It will facilitate collaboration among all stakeholders responsible for ensuring the sustainability of the area’s diverse wildlife, landscapes, and farming practices.

Natural England has a legal obligation to protect sites that showcase the country’s most significant wildlife and biodiversity. We understand that farming will play a crucial role in achieving this goal. Since the review’s release, we have initiated efforts to rebuild trust with farmers and advised Defra to ensure that commoners receive adequate support to maintain profitable farming operations that also benefit nature. We are eager to collaborate with the Land Use Management Group to develop plans for peat restoration, tree planting, and sustainable grazing that will rejuvenate Dartmoor for all who cherish it.

David Fursdon, Chair of the Review, emphasized:

I am gratified to see the Government endorsing many of our recommendations. Those entrusted with the future of Dartmoor and its unique features must come together transparently to discuss practical steps for its restoration and enhancement. Careful management and adequate funding are essential for this opportunity—one that may not present itself again.

Since the publication of the Review, Defra has been proactive in addressing its recommendations, including the launch of an enhanced moorland offer under the Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) scheme, which targets various grazing and vegetation management issues identified in the review.

Furthermore, Defra has communicated with all Higher Level Stewardship (HLS) agreement holders to clarify details and propose further annual extensions for HLS agreements through 2025.